Limited time only: Get pro member benefits for less than $5/month. Access Classes, Stats, Priority Directory listing and more!Upgrade now
A A A
     
0

Differing Opinions

Published August 14th, 2011

Generally when I take a photo I sort of have an idea what I'd like it to look like ultimately when I convert it to black and white. I spend some time looking at whats there and what parts can be brought out or pushed back, this can depend upon conditions but more often than not my mood.

On my recent trip to the yorkshire coast I paid a couple of visits to Whitby. I'd known of the pier for a while and its wonderful curving boardwalk. I'd already visited the day before but it was packed with people so decided to get up before the crack of dawn - I was staying in Hull - to get there before hoards of people arrived. First of all - what a cracking drive it was over Fylingdales and the Yorkshire Wolds - for those into driving at that time in the morning the roads are just ace. So I arrived adrenalin pumping.

I quickly headed towards the shot I'd wanted to take, it was clear so I spent the next hour alone getting the shot I wanted. My mood was still one of excitement and exhilaration as I remember, and I wanted a dramatic shot - I pictured dark clouds zooming across the sky

Fast forward to the following weekend when I get chance to look at the shots and start to process. Looking at the shot it took me back to that drive and the scene before me, and I knew exactly what I wanted. So off into lightroom, photoshop, silver efex pro 2 et al - and it started to take shape. I went back to it a few times through the course of the day, and finally I was happy. (Image 1 below).

As ever I waited to show my wife, the reaction wasn't what I was expecting, hmm, yeah its ok, its just hmm you know. At that point I knew she hated it, perhaps if I tone it down a bit - yeah maybe that would work.

So I start from scratch again with a less dramatic, perhaps lighter and brighter image in mind. When I'd finished reprocessing I presented back to my wife - yep now that's - that's much better.

I know where my wife is coming from with this and I do like the end result, possibly more real and more balanced - more believable even, and well maybe she has a point and the lighter is the one I will post as the finished article. That said its the first one that's closer to how I felt at the time.

So what do you think, is the first just over done? Or have I missed the mark on both. My wife now says the second is a bit wishy washy - I can't win !!!!

Hit 'read more' to see the second image

V2?webp=true&sig=4752e6bdf74efcf71b92a8c868f6cfdaf97793adff94890e80467a19e1cc0e41

Untitled

Whitby Pier - processed based on my mood at the time

V2?webp=true&sig=9ed3a6b5ff538bb09a0f53f17c347eb640e6972fdba90d6b42addbc113856487

Untitled

Whitby Pier - processed more conservatively.

Login or sign up to comment.

mortwatkins
Watkins (inactive)  about 6 years ago

I have to agree completely with Nicole, but for me it's the way the wooden boards are emphasised in the more contrasty version. They really stand out. Your horizon line is excellent, too!

Bernhard_Sonderhuesken
Bernhard Sonderhuesken  about 6 years ago

For me it's the first one. Trust your mood.

NicoleBleck
Nicole Bleck  about 6 years ago

Hello
I personally like the photo with the strongest contrasts ... the view is run in the deep and come through the darker the sky tower in the middle good effect ... but it is also destined always an emotional and / or a matter of taste
regards nicole
sorry for my bad english ;-)